Our Method
The Matrice
Arboricole®
1Observe2Analyze3Decide
The Matrice Arboricole® structures our expert approach by combining the different criteria observed, from the diagnosis of the tree to the assessment of the risk, to the definition of recommendations and the monitoring of its evolution.
Tree assessment
Each assessment begins with a thorough observation of the tree and its environment: its health, biomechanical analysis using the VTA method, and site constraints. If necessary, additional measurements are taken to determine the internal condition of the wood. You will receive an objective, well-reasoned, and documented opinion.
Tree risk assessment
The observed defects are assessed using the QTRA method: probability of failure, presence of people or property, severity of consequences. The risk is quantified, not estimated "by sight." This allows you to make informed decisions and justify your choices.
Tree care recommendations
Following the assessment, we propose the most appropriate measures based on the tree's condition and the site's challenges: monitoring, follow-up, pruning, bracing, or, as a last resort, felling. Our priority is to preserve the tree whenever safety permits.
Our recommendations are established independently of any work service: you are free to have the work carried out by the company of your choice.
Tree monitoring
Monitoring allows you to observe the evolution of trees over time. Each tree is mapped, and its periodic checks are recorded in our application: the history is centralized, and recommendations are adjusted to the development of each tree. You maintain a clear view of your tree stock, year after year.
Before any compensation measures are implemented, we assess the tree's heritage value using a recognized scale. This assessment takes into account the species, dimensions, health, landscape value, location, and ecological functions of the tree. It allows us to justify compensation, inform management decisions, and, where applicable, estimate any damages.
Remplacer l’impression par une démarche reproductible
When faced with a tree, each person involved may have their own impression. The Tree Matrix® replaces this impression with a reproducible approach: the same criteria are observed, noted, and compared for each tree. Two trees with the same characteristics lead to consistent conclusions, and each decision can be explained and justified.
The three phases of the Matrice
Observe
L’arbre, son environnement, ses usages : état sanitaire, architecture, signes biomécaniques, sol, cibles potentielles.
La méthode VTA ↓Analyze
Interpréter les défauts à la lumière des réactions de l’arbre (méthode VTA), puis chiffrer le risque selon QTRA lorsque des personnes ou des biens sont exposés.
La méthode QTRA ↓Decide
Hiérarchiser les mesures, de la simple surveillance à l’abattage en dernier recours, et fixer le délai du prochain contrôle.
Les mesures ↓La méthode VTA
The diagnosis is based on the Visual Tree Assessment (VTA), Developed by biomechanics expert Claus Mattheck, its principle is that a tree reacts to stresses by reinforcing the most stressed areas. Cover ridges, bulges, ribs, cracks, and compression folds are all signals that we learn to read. They allow us to distinguish a defect that the tree is compensating for from a defect that is progressing faster than its capacity to react.
- Système racinaire et collet
- Tronc
- Charpentières et houppier
- Environnement
The examination focuses successively on the root system and root collar, the trunk, the main branches and the crown, and then on the environment: soil type and compaction, recent work, wind exposure, and changes in land use around the tree. When observation is insufficient to reach a conclusion, further investigations into the internal condition of the wood may be recommended.
The QTRA method
When people or property are exposed, the risk is assessed according to the method QTRA (Quantified Tree Risk Assessment) ; Anthony Jamet is a registered QTRA user under number 11171. Rather than classifying a tree as "dangerous" or "healthy," QTRA estimates the probability of significant damage occurring within a year, based on three components:
The target
Qui ou quoi pourrait être atteint, et à quelle fréquence : fréquentation piétonne, trafic routier, valeur d’un bien. Elle est classée en six plages de valeur.
The size
Le diamètre de la partie susceptible de rompre (une branche, une charpentière, l’arbre entier), qui conditionne la gravité de l’impact.
The probability of failure
La probabilité que cette partie rompe au cours des douze prochains mois, classée en sept plages.
The combination of these three values gives a Risk of Harm exprimé sous forme de rapport : par exemple 1/250 000, soit une chance sur 250 000, chaque année, qu’un dommage significatif survienne.
Interpreting the result: recognized thresholds
This result is compared to the thresholds of the risk tolerability framework (Tolerability of Risk) of the British Health and Safety Executive, used for many everyday risks:
Aucune intervention n’est nécessaire au titre de la sécurité.
On met en balance le coût et l’intérêt d’une intervention, y compris la perte des bénéfices apportés par l’arbre. Lorsqu’il est supporté par le public, un risque de 1/10 000 ou plus n’est en règle générale pas considéré comme tolérable.
Une mesure de réduction s’impose.
This approach avoids two pitfalls: felling a tree as a precaution when the risk is actually very low, or leaving a tree standing when the risk is not controlled. It also makes the risk comparable from one tree to another, which allows for prioritizing interventions across an entire tree population.
Des mesures proportionnées
Les préconisations découlent directement de l’analyse :
- Surveillance
- Contrôle rapproché
- Réduction ou allègement de couronne
- Suppression d’une charpentière
- Guying
- Aménagement de l’usage du site (déplacer un banc, un cheminement, un stationnement)
- Felling, as a last resort
Chaque mesure est assortie d’un délai et de la date du prochain contrôle.
A method that adapts to the scale
The same approach applies to a single tree in a garden, to trees in a condominium, or to the heritage of a municipality. On a large scale, the Matrix allows trees to be classified by priority and a multi-year management plan to be developed.
What the method brings you
Justified decisions
Chaque préconisation renvoie aux observations qui la fondent, ce qui permet de l’expliquer à un assureur, un voisin, un conseil syndical ou des élus.
A vision through time
Les contrôles successifs sont comparables entre eux : on voit si un défaut évolue et si les mesures prises ont fonctionné.
A common language
Le risque exprimé en probabilité se compare aux autres risques que gère une collectivité ou un gestionnaire, et s’explique simplement : « une chance sur un million par an » parle à tout le monde.
Clear priorities
Sur un ensemble d’arbres, le classement par niveau de risque et par délai permet de concentrer les moyens là où ils sont utiles.
The Matrice Arboricole®
Should you apply this method to your trees? Let's talk about it.
A tree, a park, or a piece of communal heritage: we define it with you. the scope of the mission, From diagnosis to risk assessment and follow-up, we provide a detailed, no-obligation quote. We operate in Maine-et-Loire, Loire-Atlantique, and throughout Western France, as well as in Île-de-France and Occitanie.