Évaluation du risque arboricole
Expertise · Évaluer

Tree risk assessment

A tree with a defect isn't necessarily dangerous. The risk depends on what's underneath it: a weakened oak in the middle of a meadow doesn't pose the same level of risk as one above a playground or a busy road. Assessing tree risk helps answer the real question: is this risk acceptable, and if not, what should be done?

Badge QTRA Registered User – Anthony Jamet, utilisateur enregistré n° 11171
Registered user QTRA no. 11171

The QTRA method

We use the QTRA (Quantified Tree Risk Assessment) method, developed in the United Kingdom and used by many tree managers. Anthony Jamet is a registered QTRA user under number 11171; this registration can be verified on the official QTRA website.

QTRA combines three components:

  • the target : the presence of people, vehicles or property in the area where the tree or a branch could fall, and their frequency of occupancy; ;
  • the size of the part likely to fail : a small dead branch and a main branch do not have the same consequences; ;
  • the probability of failure : estimated from the diagnosis of the tree and its defects.

These three elements give a quantified risk, expressed as a probability, which is compared to recognized tolerance thresholds. Risk is no longer estimated "by eye": it is quantified, compared and justified.

Why quantify the risk?

To make a proportionate decision

On évite à la fois l’abattage inutile d’un arbre sain et l’oubli d’un défaut réellement dangereux.

To prioritize

Sur un parc, une résidence ou un patrimoine communal, les risques chiffrés permettent de classer les arbres et de traiter d’abord ce qui est prioritaire.

To justify your choices

Une décision appuyée sur une méthode reconnue se défend auprès d’un assureur, d’un voisin, d’un conseil syndical ou d’élus.

To track over time

Le même calcul, répété lors des contrôles, montre si la situation évolue.

How does the evaluation process work?

  1. Tree diagnosis — The evaluation is based on a tree diagnosis : health status, biomechanical reading, observed defects.
  2. Target analysis — We are recording the uses around the tree: roads, pathways, buildings, parking, playgrounds, visitor numbers.
  3. Risk calculation — Each significant defect is subject to a QTRA calculation.
  4. Recommendations — If the risk exceeds the acceptable threshold, we indicate the measures that allow it to be brought back to a tolerable level: modify the use under the tree, lighten a part, put in place monitoring or, as a last resort, cut it down.

Act on the target, not just on the tree

One of QTRA's contributions is to remind us that the risk can also be reduced by modifying what is under the tree: moving a bench, a parking space, a pathway, or temporarily closing an area. These solutions often allow us to preserve a remarkable tree.

What you receive

A report which presents, for each tree or defect assessed: the target selected, the size of the part concerned, the probability of breakage, the calculated risk, its comparison with the thresholds, the recommendations and the time before reassessment.

For whom?

Individuals concerned about a tree near their house, co-ownerships and trustees, managers of establishments open to the public, companies, communities responsible for trees on the edge of roads, in parks or schoolyards.

Our recommendations are independent: we do not carry out any work on the trees (no pruning, no felling, no planting).